This WAS my favorite restaurant. I won't go there again.
New owners
The waitress was very nice. We didn't stay.
Offers a very small menu, no more kettles of soup with your meals salad not impressive no fresh bread. Had to have been store bought. I ordered a Prime Rib dinner.. every item on my plate was cold, the meat was over cooked with no flavor. I seriously was so upset that I couldn't eat.( it was my birthday)...$24.00.
Great service, food was amazing. Several food options. Dinner menu offers seven appetizers, three salads, ten entrèes, Friday night sea food buffet, and four desert options along with a small children's menu. Nice relaxing out door seating and a large dinning area.
Delicious food, super friendly service. Love the atmosphere and warmth. We had flat bread pizzas, the Roethlisburger, French dip and a fish fry. Everyone was pleased, plenty of food, good bar and popcorn.
The meal was awful!
Nice place too bad they had no bar tender on for Sunday football. Took a while to get a drink. Very slow to check back with you to see if you wanted anything. Hope they get their act together or they will not last long.
I had been here around 10 years ago and had a wonderful experience. Cauldren of soup and salad with a good meal. Things have changed. New owners, new menu, not for the good.
The Old Mill is a US Cafe based in Old Forge, New York. The Old Mill is located at 2888 NY-28, Old Forge, NY 13420, USA.
Please contact with The Old Mill using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find The Old Mill opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.